Guides

How to check that a reference is real.

Volpi looks a reference up in public scholarly databases and tells you whether it exists, whether its details match yours, and whether it has been retracted.

Before you start

Checks use the internet, and only when the Online checks setting in References allows it. There are three choices: When I click (the default), Automatic, which also checks papers right after you import them, and Off, which never contacts the internet.

Check one reference

  1. Open References. It lists every source in the project.
  2. If the reference is not there yet, choose Add references. Paste a DOI, an arXiv id or a PubMed id and choose Look up, or choose Type it in, or paste BibTeX, RIS or CSL JSON.
  3. Choose Verify on the reference. To do the whole library at once, use Check every unchecked reference online.
  4. Read the badge, and the reason beside it.

What the badges mean

BadgeMeaning
VerifiedA database has this work and it agrees with yours: the title closely matches, the first author is the same and the year is within one.
LikelyA database has a work that is probably this one, but the details are not close enough to be sure.
MismatchYour details disagree with the database. The DOI may belong to a different paper, or the authors or year differ.
Not foundNo record came close enough.
RetractedThe database marks this work as retracted.
Verified by youYou marked it yourself with I checked it myself.

When the badge is not Verified

  • Choose Compare to see your details and the database record side by side. If yours are right, choose Mine is right.
  • If Volpi says the DOI points to a different paper, the DOI was probably mistyped or copied from the wrong line. Remove the wrong DOI and check again.
  • Books, theses and older works are often missing from these databases. When you have checked one yourself, choose I checked it myself.
  • Recheck runs the lookup again after you correct something.

Where Volpi looks, and what it sends

A reference with a DOI is looked up in Crossref, then in OpenAlex if Crossref does not have it. One with an arXiv id is looked up in arXiv, and one with a PubMed id in PubMed. Without any identifier, Volpi searches Crossref, then OpenAlex, with a short citation: the first author's family name, the year, the title and the journal.

Nothing else is sent. Not the paper you are writing, not your notes, not your name.

What a check cannot tell you

  • Verified means the work exists and is described correctly. It does not mean the work supports your sentence.
  • Retraction flags come from what Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed record. A retraction none of them has recorded will not show.
  • Not found is not proof that a reference is invented. It means none of these databases has a close match.

Written for Volpi 0.1.1. Button names are the ones in that version.

Read next